Skip to product information
Pre-Order Variety Lemon Butta Pie LOCAL PICK-UP ONLY
$36.95 USD
"Local Pick-Up Only", select "Pick-Up" at checkout not "ship" as this product will "NOT" ship.
🍋 Lemon Butta Variety Pie – Pre-Order for Thanksgiving
The pie that put us on the map.
Our original Lemon Butta Pie is a hometown legend, decadent, silky, and unforgettable. Baked with love and fresh citrus, this rich and creamy pie features a smooth lemon custard filling over a buttery cookie crust, topped powdered sugar. It’s the perfect balance of sweet, tart, and melt-in-your-mouth magic.
There are five flavors included in this variety pie:
-Salted Caramel Snickers
-Salted Caramel Toffee
-Blueberry
-Chocolate Ganache
-Original Lemon
Why everyone loves it:
🍋 Bright, buttery lemon custard
🥧 Buttery cookie-style crust and a new flavor packed in each piece
✨ Handcrafted with real ingredients, no shortcuts
Pick-Up Instructions: Your order must be picked up on Tuesday November 25th between 9am-2pm in the Eastern Market sheds.
Pickup available at Holiday Local Pick-Up at Eastern Market
Usually ready in 5+ days